Newsletter:

Skip Navigation LinksHome > News > Linux & Open Source > CeBIT 08: Red Hat says Australia missed OOXML opportunity

CeBIT 08: Red Hat says Australia missed OOXML opportunity

By Liz Tay
20 May 2008 03:59PM
Tags: red | hat | australia | ooxml | odf | iso | microsoft | standards | australia | cebit

Australia may have missed an opportunity to promote open technology by abstaining from the recent OOXML vote, according to Linux distribution vendor Red Hat.

Speaking at the Open CeBIT conference in Sydney today, Red Hat’s Asia Pacific Senior Product Manager Frank Feldmann said he was disappointed that OOXML has been accepted as an international standard.

The standardisation of OOXML comes after an International Standards Organisation (ISO) vote that closed on Saturday 29 March.

Australia was one of 41 countries that participated in a decision to make OOXML (Open Office XML) an international standard alongside the existing standard, OpenDocument Format (ODF).

Denmark, Germany, Japan and Singapore were among 24 countries that voted in favour of Microsoft’s format. Eight countries, including China and New Zealand disapproved, while nine countries, including Australia, chose to abstain from voting.

“I was very disappointed that Australia did not vote,” Feldmann said. “Your New Zealand cousins did, and they said no.”

“You really missed an opportunity there,” he said.

Feldmann compared the code required to format red text in ODF and OOXML, which is developed and promoted by Microsoft.

While the Open Source ODF was found to use the same code in text documents, presentations and spreadsheets, OOXML required different commands for each.

Furthermore, OOXML was originally developed for the proprietary Microsoft Office software suite, and as such, may not be implementable as easily on some platforms.

“A lot of OOXML development came not from Open Source; it came from Microsoft’s office suite,” Feldmann argued.

“To me, it’s an absolute no brainer. Should OOXML be an international standard? It should not,” he said.

The burden of blame for the OOXML decision was attributed to Standards Australia, which represented the country for the ISO process.

Feldmann encouraged conference attendees to urge policy makers to build a collaborative, open environment that enables and rewards innovation.

“Innovation should be defined by what you do, not what you own,” he said. “Keep putting pressure on your government.”

   


Ads by Google


Thoughts on this article? Add a comment below.
Comments: 2
This is so true.

Abstaining from the vote means that Australia does not have an opinion. How can this be the case, everyone has an opinion.

One could easily conclude that if there are no major objections by participants then a Yes vote should be given.

Otherwise, if consensus is not reached, then the format should not go ahead and a No vote should be given.

Australia, by voting Abstain, essentially indicated that Australia does not care about document standards.

iTnews - comments icon Posted by AaronMay 22, 2008 11:59 AM
Thanks to the three readers who have written in to point out that OOXML will not *replace* ODF; the two formats will coexist as international standards. The story has been updated to reflect this.

Also, Standards Australia has written in to point out that its decision to abstain from the ISO vote reflects “many months of consultation and discussion”, during which it was decided that “a consensus position on the vote would never emerge”. Standards Australia further points out that Australia would not have changed the outcome of the ISO vote, no matter which position it took.

iTnews - comments icon Posted by Liz TayMay 22, 2008 5:11 PM
Report this comment as offensive:

   * Indicates information we require to process your submission.

Name: *
Email: *
Reason for offense: *
Your report will not be displayed.  
Name:
*
 
Email:
(will not be displayed)
*
 
Comment:
(HTML not permitted)
*
 
Validation
*

Enter the code you see below:

 

 
 
 
 
 






Product Reviews now available on iTnews.com.au

TopTopics
(3705) -  microsoft
(2051) -  telstra
(1911) -  broadband
(1600) -  network
(1453) -  windows
(1381) -  mobile
(1299) -  security
(1177) -  blackberry
(1057) -  apple
(1021) -  data
(910) -  nbn
(784) -  storm
(761) -  television
(732) -  linux
(725) -  internet